What If? - Edition #22
Let your imagination run free as you decide how things should be for a range of wizarding situations! Share your ideas in the comments to earn yourself a prize for your creativity.
- From : Raeh Thatcher
Meeting place for Potterheads
Become part of the most amazing online magical universe and meet lots of friendly people that share the same interests as you! We can't wait to meet you!
Enrol Here
Michael Hearthstone Probably the cloak. Michael's practically invisible already, why not complete the image (or rather, complete the blank space where the image should have been visible)
Anna Untyde Once I wanted Elder wand but now I think the elder wand creates a never ending cycle of violence and guarantees betrayal. But I choose Invisibility cloak,it doesn't make you a target for any rival.. Anna loves peace and no harm for her and her friends. Invisibility cloak gives you a free and peaceful life. It never fades,tears,or fails under spells like regular disillusionment charms!!
Ignatius Bolingbroke the elder wand without a doubt! Iggy's middle name is Hereward after one of the owners of the strongest wand in the world :D he would think himself unstoppable with mastery of the elder wand.
Vera LaKulina Once upon a time I would have said the elder wand without even hessitating, and while the stone is at times very tempting, even if we know it does not work the way we wish to, I think the smart choice is to go for the cloak. Hopefully I would then get to do what the first owner did and pass it down to my kids to they could be safe from the evils of the world too.
Lucinda Nightshade Lucy would choose the philosopher's stone. Not for its power, but rather the fact that she can utilise it for others. Helping the poor and the sick, you know? The Elder Wand defeats connection with a witch or wizard, by basing it entirely off competition. The Resurrection Stone is something not to be fiddled with. Dead people lived their lives to the fullest, we let them rest. And escaping death with a cloak completely eliminates "death's" meaning. We pass when we pass. The point of life is to make the best of it while it lasts. Otherwise, is it really life? A gift from death sounds sketchy to her anyways. Like it's part of a bigger plot she won't want to be a part of.
Ginny Hazel For Ginny, the Elder Wand is useful, but being someone attached to her origins and remembering the phrase "the wand chooses the wizard," she would prefer to keep her beloved wand. The Resurrection Stone has a nearly useless power since it cannot truly bring the dead back to life and would only bring chaos and madness. She would probably take up the Invisibility Cloak; it's not dangerous, but it's useful for important situations or escapades with friends.
Ezra Moore Ezra is still a happy boy with no traumas or loss of loved ones yet (bless him), so no need for the Resurrection Stone; Invisibility Cloak wouldn't sound too much different from an Invisibility Potion to him; he knows he's not that good of a spellcaster, so no Elder Wand (although I'd love for him to hold it so that I could see all the spectacular ways it would backfire); Philosopher's Stone sounds intriguing enough to him, although it'd frustrate him SO much, causing him to take long breaks before going back to studying it. He'd probably never manage to properly use it, but it would be his life-long challenge